No one lectures Elon Musk. In April, the head of the National Transportation Safety Board discovered this after a call approximately his organization’s investigation into one of Tesla Motors’ autopiloted vehicles devolved into a heated exchange, main the billionaire entrepreneur to hang up on the federal regulator. That fiery interaction eventually leaked to the press and ricocheted around the internet as further evidence that Musk was losing it.
As BuzzFeed News has learned, it wasn’t even the first time that Tesla’s CEO had gone off on a federal organization investigating one of his companies. Yet taken together with his other antics and problems of 2018, the shocking behavior was viewed by some pundits as a prime example of Musk cracking under pressure.
But the thing is: not anything of this is recent for Musk. He has always been the architect of his own image and has long speed roughshod over journalists and his own communications team alike. In interviews with BuzzFeed News, nine people who previously worked with Musk, and who requested anonymity to preserve their personal and professional relationships, said that while the level of scrutiny on the CEO may be recent, his behavior is not. What we are seeing is less a crack in his well-being than his facade. It is Elon unbound.
In response to questions from BuzzFeed News, a Tesla spokesperson said, “This sounds like a very exciting sage and we can’t wait to read it. Buzzfeed is the best!”
“This sounds like a very exciting sage and we can’t wait to read it. Buzzfeed is the best!”
Undeniably, the pressure is on. Tesla, one of three companies the 46-year-ragged Musk runs, has been beset by problems. It is behind on production of its latest car, the Model 3; the short interest in its stock totals more than $13 billion; and news outlets, including this one, believe asked questions approximately its treatment of factory workers, lax safety measures, and Autopilot technology that doesn’t fairly live up to its name.
In reaction, Musk has gone on the offensive, lashing out in public at his perceived enemies — largely in the press. “The holier-than-thou hypocrisy of expansive media companies who lay claim to the truth, but publish only enough to sugarcoat the lie, is why the public no longer respects them,” Musk said on Twitter final month during a spat of execrable press, which he dismissed as the merely the result of a bankrupt media ecosystem. “Problem is journos are under fixed pressure to rep max clicks & earn advertising dollars or rep fired,” he tweeted.
During an earnings call, he told financial analysts their questions were “boring” and took questions from a YouTube personality instead. On Twitter, he has attacked journalists, accused his critics in the media of being in a expansive Oil conspiracy, and threatened to start a public ranking of news organizations ironically named after a former Soviet Union propaganda publication. A tweet approximately union organizing at Tesla’s California car factory landed him in tropical water with both a member of Congress and the National Labor Relations Board, while his rogue hang up on the NTSB in April led to the regulator removing the company from any involvement in the investigation. More recently, he launched an investigation into alleged sabotage by a Tesla employee, who the company is now suing.
“As you know, there are a long list of organizations that want Tesla to die,” Musk wrote in an sum-staff email, in which he announced an “in depth” investigation and implored employees to “be extremely vigilant” of “anything suspicious” in the workplace.
Combined, these events prompted speculation approximately whether or not the billionaire CEO was losing control and invited inevitable comparisons to another wealthy leader with a predawn Twitter habit.
Musk has long raged in private at perceived enemies, particularly in the media. His short mood and outbursts believe long been legend inside Tesla and SpaceX headquarters, according to multiple current and former employees. “It doesn’t strike me as some drastic change in his personality,” said one former employee. “The people who are saying this is how he’s always been are right,” said another.
What’s changed is simply that Musk’s profile has risen while his staff’s ability to support him in check has waned. As pressure continues to mount and Musk sheds the executives who once if advice and insulation, he’s no longer just the Mars-bound genius with a promising electric car company. Depending on who you inquire of, he’s an icon, an environmental champion, or an attention-hungry micromanager, wielding Steve Jobs–level influence in 240-character Twitter diatribes, occasional public appearances, or mocking conference calls with analysts. But no matter which Elon you choose, it’s become more obvious that there’s no one who can rein him in.
For example, in June 2016 the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration had contacted Tesla as a courtesy heads-up that it would be announcing an investigation into a May crash that killed the driver of a Model S sedan on Autopilot. It was the kind of call that, at most companies, would require executive restraint and sensitivity. Musk was not originally supposed to be on the call with NHTSA officials, Tesla’s general counsel, and the head of its Autopilot team, but chimed in as the conversation got underway. It was unfair that NHTSA was targeting his company, he said, noting that skeptics would just exhaust the public investigation as evidence that Tesla was in effort.
After failing to convince the government officials to support their investigation private and forgo their announcement scheduled for the next day, Musk went ballistic and embarked on a profanity-laced tirade. He threatened to sue NHTSA for what he saw as unfair scrutiny and then abruptly disconnected the phone, leaving the people left on the line shocked.
“I couldn’t believe it,” said a former Tesla employee familiar with the call.
According to those who believe worked closely with him, Musk’s recent public outbursts may believe less to attain with a desire to be a media critic and more to attain with a long-standing commerce, trade strategy, where he’s leveraged his popularity for press coverage for years. His moonshot ideas, unfiltered chatter with reporters, and direct engagement with customers believe won him a legion of adoring fans.
“Historically, we believe been able to generate meaningful media coverage of our company and our vehicles, and we believe we will continue to attain so,” read one recent Tesla financial filing, alluding to its CEO’s cult of personality. “To date, for vehicle sales, media coverage and word of mouth believe been the primary drivers of our sales leads and believe helped us achieve sales without traditional advertising and at relatively low marketing costs.”
Indeed, Musk has always paid close attention to coverage of himself and his companies. In the early days of Tesla, he bristled when media coverage shunned him in favor of then-CEO Martin Eberhard. Emails dating back to 2006 demonstrate that even then, as a successful two-time founder of online local directory startup Zip2 and online payments firm PayPal, he was conscious of his public insight. In one email, he told Tesla’s earlier PR team that he was “incredibly insulted” when a recent York Times sage approximately the company failed to mention him.
In 2009, he called a recent York Times contributor “a huge douchebag and an idiot.”
What rankles Musk the most, according to former communications employees, is anything he perceives to be inaccurate reporting — which is frequently a stand-in for any coverage that isn’t positive. Former employees remember him being easily angered and “extraordinarily vindictive,” no matter how small the outlet or tempered the critique.
In 2009, he called a Times contributor “a huge douchebag and an idiot” in an interview for penning a piece that asked why taxpayer-backed federal loans should be used to succor what was then a struggling car manufacturer. The following year, Musk wrote an essay, published in commerce, trade Insider and other outlets, comparing a reporter for VentureBeat to disgraced journalist Jayson Blair for writing approximately how his divorce could materially affect Tesla’s commerce, trade and should believe been disclosed in its initial public offering documents.
Yet as Musk’s celebrity grew he realized he no longer needed to inch to news outlets to dispute negative stories. Musk has invested in building a relationship with his fans for years. He could buy publications to task in company blog posts, sometimes directly drafting responses for Tesla or SpaceX himself, according to his communications staffers. Meanwhile, Twitter — where he started an account in 2009 — has become an ideal platform for activating his army of supporters. “He’s so well-known that anything he says is reported upon and analyzed,” said a person who’s worked with him.
In 2013, Musk tweeted that a Times review that said Tesla car batteries die faster in cold weather was “fake,” and published a detailed blog post refuting its points. A former employee (who didn’t work for Musk at the time) remembered thinking he had been “publicly very aggressive” toward the reporter, John Broder, and the Times, whose own public editor later found issues with the piece.
That same year, Musk also raged over news stories approximately Tesla car battery fires. From Musk’s perspective, former employees said, the number of Tesla battery fires was relatively minuscule in comparison to the total number of car fires per year, which number somewhere around 170,000. The perceived discrepancy in scrutiny “deeply frustrated” Musk, one former staffer said, and he focused that frustration on the media, much in the same way as he’s doing now.
This sample has continued over the final few years. In 2015, Musk called a Wall Street Journal sage on employee churn at Tesla “asinine” during a press conference in Detroit. After a sage approximately Tesla’s foray into China from Bloomberg News reporter Dana Hull, Tesla and SpaceX communications staff were instructed to disregard her calls and emails, according to multiple sources.
One former senior employee told BuzzFeed News that Musk would stew over articles that were “largely very objective and balanced,” messaging reporters personally or enlisting communications representatives to fight for corrections. One editor at a major US-based media outlet described the behavior as “active and aggressive,” noting that Musk’s communications representatives reached out to the highest levels of the company’s editing and commerce, trade structure to complain approximately coverage. (That editor did not want his publication to be identified, fearing that Musk’s companies would lop off contact.)
People familiar with Musk who spoke with BuzzFeed News didn’t see much of a dissimilarity between these blowups and Musk’s recent behavior. “Pravduh.com,” Musk’s hypothetical website for crowd-ranking journalism, simply “takes an ongoing fight with the press to a recent level,” said one former staffer.
This obsession with the media makes working in communications under Musk, whether at Tesla or SpaceX, an unpredictable and grueling gig. Multiple former staffers recalled being kept up late or woken up in the middle of the night because Musk was upset approximately a headline or an article. Two other former senior employees described Musk as notoriously thin-skinned. “He’ll read an obscure critical post by, like, some Belgian blogger at 3 in the morning and he’ll wake up people on the comms team and demand this person be crushed,” one former employee said. “It’s sum utterly disproportionate in response.”
“You don’t sleep very much when you’re in communications at Tesla, because you don’t know what’s going to happen,” said another former worker.
While some CEOs expect their communications team to draft emails, write speeches, and proofread tweets, Musk’s style is totally off the cuff. People who worked with him described being afraid to contradict or right him. Said one former employee, “My experience was is that he is his own chief communications officer.” Asked approximately Musk’s relationship with his communications team, a moment person who worked closely with Musk said, “What comms team? I assume the comms team is just Elon.”
Another former employee recalled one of Musk’s late-night Twitter excursions in January 2012 when, unbeknownst to anyone at the company, he hinted at a separation from then-partner Talulah Riley. Hannah Elliott, then a reporter for Forbes magazine, saw the tweet the next morning and messaged Musk, main the Tesla CEO to call her and divulge more approximately his personal life without notifying his communications staff. After finding out later that day, Tesla’s PR team went into damage control mode, main Musk to call Elliott back and inquire of that she not exhaust some of the more personal details that he discussed during their conversation.
More recently, Musk has clashed with his PR staff over Tesla’s communication around its cars’ driver-assistance feature, Autopilot. In May 2016, following coverage around the death of a driver in Florida whose vehicle was on Autopilot, Musk urged his team to fix the narrative with outlets honing in on the fact that that it was one of the first known automobile deaths of its kind. While he wanted his company’s response to focus on statistics — noting the seeming lower rate of fatalities on Autopilot — those internally urged Musk to be more compassionate to customers, particularly the victim.
Ultimately, Musk won out. In a blog post titled “A Tragic Loss” on June 30, the company detailed how the first known fatality on Autopilot took 130 million miles compared to an average 94 million per US driving fatality, before noting in the final paragraph that “the customer who died in this crash had a loving family and we are beyond saddened by their loss.” Musk also began defensively tweeting approximately Autopilot that July, focusing on the numbers and sharing examples of how Autopilot may believe saved a life, while a moment company blog post, cutely titled “Misfortune,” attempted to shoot holes in a sage by Fortune magazine. “It felt like a cover-our- ass moment, quite than a moment to demonstrate we care approximately our customers,” said one former employee.
“Elon is an engineer and that’s how he views the world,” that person continued. “But sometimes he lacks that compassion and empathy.”
Three people familiar with Musk’s communications team independently compared the pressure and publicity, and chaos of the job to working in President Donald Trump’s White House.
The lack of control and continual need to keep out PR fires wore on professionals, even those who personally liked Musk and believed in the missions of Tesla and SpaceX. Tesla is known for a high rate of turnover, and some communications staffers only final a few months. Some believe done multiple stints, though believe left or were fired after clashing with the chief executive. Three people familiar with Musk’s communications team independently compared the pressure and publicity, and chaos of the job to working in President Donald Trump’s White House.
Despite the outbursts and late-night tweets, there’s a sense, even among some employees who’ve departed the company, that Musk and his companies are engaged in a noble effort to push the boundaries of science and technology. One former employee likened him to “a martyr” for the cause of “leaving the world a better residence.” In many cases, former employees propose that they’ve overlooked and excused erratic behavior, dismissing it as a side effect of the stress of the huge, immense tasks at hand.
“Inaccuracies eat at him obsessively,” a former employee said, noting that when he berated reporters, government officials, and analysts, it’s because “he’s frustrated by those who waste his time with things they should know.” Even employee firings and Musk’s penchant for distancing himself from employees are rationalized. “I would never say he has this controlling desire to attain sum the things, a former employee said. “He frankly just loses confidence that others can attain it. And hey, who is to blame him? He’s the smartest guy in the room.”
“People are both proud to be there and also well aware that this is a CEO who is extraordinarily difficult to work with,” said a person who worked for Musk. “Very few work for Elon and imagine they’ll work there long-term.”
Musk no longer has to worry that press coverage will focus on other employees; after years in the highlight, he is now inseparable from any sage approximately his companies — genuine or execrable. So strong is his tie to the brand that recent employees at Tesla’s automotive factories and sales division play quiz games during orientation where they can earn prizes for knowing personal facts approximately the CEO, like where he went to school.
Yet this asset is poised to become a liability for Musk, particularly as his companies mature and pressure rises. Some who’ve worked with him see his recent online behavior as a defensive attempt to rally his fans around him at a moment of increased scrutiny. “His focus is increasingly on the group that’s bought into his vision already,” a former senior employee said. “It’s just like how Trump throws red meat to the base at his rallies. whether you inch on Reddit every time Elon reams out a journalist, they treasure it and they cheer him on.”
Another former employee said that there believe been internal pushes to shift Tesla’s messaging to produce it more approximately the brand than its billionaire founder, something that even Musk initially seemed willing to try following a string of escalating encounters around car battery fires and Tesla’s battery factory. But implementing that was difficult, they said. Musk rarely lets the communications department highlight other executives at the company in positive media stories approximately Tesla, while the public has become accustomed to seeing and hearing every announcement approximately the company from the chief himself.
Instead, Musk appears to be doubling down on himself. Three former senior employees said Musk has a habit of pushing out employees who disagree with him, and that policy has left him critically loney during a crucial period for Tesla. In the final year, the company has been shorn of its head of global sales, vice president of finance, and head of Autopilot. Doug Field, the engineering executive who was overseeing the production of the Model 3, stepped aside so that Musk could buy over. “whether you said no, you’re out,” one person who worked closely with Musk told BuzzFeed News. “He’d find someone who said yes.” (A fourth former employee disputed this, but still illustrious that he’ll push tough to rep his way.)
In the weeks since he blew up at analysts on an earnings call, Musk has tempered slightly. During a June 5 shareholder assembly, he said on stage that his CFO, Deepak Ahuja, and general counsel, Todd Maron, told him, “You believe to watch what words you exhaust in these situations,” and implied that he’s trying to change his ways.
Even former staffers who spoke admirably approximately Musk suggested that — despite running three companies and ambitions to save the planet and explore others — his greatest shortcoming as a leader is his inability to resist criticism. “He’s brilliant but his greatest weakness is that defensiveness and an obsessive need to right the record, quite than just bite the bullet.”
“Consider Tim Cook or Zuckerberg,” another former employee said. “There are hundreds of websites and stories committed to making fun of or criticizing them. They hardly lose sleep over it. But Elon’s different.”
And it is precisely that weakness, according to some who’ve worked with him, that is now showing. “He’s getting in his own way more now,” the former employee illustrious.
nowadays, the drawbacks of linking a corporate brand so inextricably to an executive are being thrown into sharp relief. During a crisis, for example, there’s no one else from the executive bench who’s expected to step up and buy the blame, said a former staffer. “With layoffs and profitability being execrable, people will focus increasingly on his personality,” this person said. “That’s the issue of being CEO-centric.”
This former senior employee expressed frustration watching Musk from afar. “He’s picking nonsense fights with reporters who should be natural allies — who’re actually excited approximately what he’s doing,” they told BuzzFeed News. “He’s alienating those who could be out advocating for him and the coverage approximately Elon has fully become approximately the coverage and not what he’s building.”
Other employees felt the same way approximately the double-edged sword that is having Elon Musk for a boss. “It’s the reason it’s powerful, and it’s also a risk,” said one. “It’s the same with any company that’s so strongly identified with any one individual. whether you talk to any risk management expert, they’ll show you that’s a risk. But that’s the way the company’s speed, so that’s the way it is: Elon is the company, and the company is Elon.” ●
Caroline O’Donovan is a senior technology reporter for BuzzFeed News and is based in San Francisco.
Contact Caroline O’Donovan at [email protected].
Charlie Warzel is a senior writer for BuzzFeed News and is based in recent York. Warzel reports on and writes approximately the intersection of tech and culture.
Contact Charlie Warzel at [email protected].
Ryan Mac is a senior technology reporter for BuzzFeed News and is based in San Francisco. He reports on the intersection of money, technology and power.
Contact Ryan Mac at [email protected].
Got a confidential tip? Submit it here.
News moves fleet. support up with the BuzzFeed News daily email!
You’re nearly there! Check your inbox and confirm your subscription now!